Showing posts with label Bohr. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bohr. Show all posts

Thursday, 5 December 2013

December 5th, 2013

"No one understands my trip to Copenhagen. Time and time again I’ve explained it. To Bohr himself, and Margrethe. To interrogators and intelligence officers, to journalists and historians. The more I've explained, the deeper the uncertainty has become. Well, I shall be happy to make one more attempt". These lines are from an award-winning 1998 play depicting this chap's legendary trip to Denmark, in the midst of the second world war more than half a century before the play opened. Apart from Niels Bohr and his wife Margrethe (both mentioned in the line), this chap featured as the third character in the play. But the line also hints at his own identity, though in a gimmicky way!

He is known predominantly for one thing he discovered, mainly because it is also named after him. But the reality is that it was but one of his great achievements.

If we're surprised that he won the Nobel at the age of 31, we should check ourselves. Because it was only his second nomination, and he had been nominated once already, at the age of 27. And the signatory of that earlier nomination was one Prof Albert Einstein.

A lot of his path-breaking work was done before he was 35, when his career faced a setback. Mainly due to the Deutsche Physik movement which politicised scientific work and demanded that the scientists should conform to the National Socialism on the rise in Germany of the 1930s. And then, after being cleared by Himmler, he had to become one of the leads of the German effort to make a fission bomb. It was during the war that his aforementioned visit to Denmark happened. What he discussed with the old mentor of his continues to be a topic of speculation, and indeed, an entire play!

As it turned out, the German effort did not succeed. This chap was arrested by the allies and questioned. Once they realised he was mainly involved in the theoretical physics related to it, and that the German project had not made much progress, they released him. In later life, he became the head of the illustrious Max Planck Institute. Though his involvement in the German bomb remains a blot on his career (as compared to someone like Otto Hahn - the discoverer of fission - who stayed away from it and risked arrest), it might perhaps be unfair, as we do not know the drivers that dictated his decision.

His landmark achievement in the 1920s was the Matrix method, which really started the Quantum Mechanics movement, and which was done using differential equations by Schrodinger almost around the same time. It was for this that he got the Nobel eventually, and was gracious enough to acknowledge publicly that his partner in the research Max Born deserved it as much as him.

But what he is universally known for was published by him in 1927 and he used a term which is closer to 'imprecision' or 'inaccuracy', than 'uncertainty'. Nonetheless, we all identify it with the term 'uncertainty', and so universally that there's even a rumour (untrue) that his epitaph reads "he lies here, somewhere".

Happy 112th birthday Werner Heisenberg!

Monday, 7 October 2013

October 7th, 2013

This chap has an anecdote associated with him which is probably fictitious, but has become a legend in its own sense, and definitely portrays accurately his aptitude in his chosen field, and his spirit of free-thinking.

He was failed in a school exam for answering the routine question about "how to measure the height of a tall building with a barometer", as "hang the barometer from the roof with a piece of string and measure the length of the string". When he challenged the result, arguing his answer is not essentially wrong, he was asked to meet an arbitrator who said the answer does not show knowledge of science or physics and so he'll need to provide a better answer, preferably more scientific. The student's response was -
"You should drop the barometer from the roof of the building, and measure the time it takes to hit the ground. Then using s = u.t + 0.5att, calculate 's' which is the height of the building. But that's bad luck on the barometer, so you can stand the barometer vertically on a clear sunny day, measure its length and the length of its shadow, measure the length of the shadow of the building, and then using the proportion compute the height of the building". Towards the end he added - "and of course if you want the usual boring orthodox way of doing this, measure the air pressure on the ground and on the roof and that should give you the height of the building".

Of course the chap needs no anecdotes to introduce him. His is unarguably one of the most breathtaking contributions to the golden era of physics, including being one of the founders of the quantum revolution. Apart from proposing a revolutionary new atomic model (for which he received the Nobel Prize in 1922, a year after his good friend Albert Einstein), he was instrumental in mentoring a generation of young physicists like Heisenberg and Pauli and making valuable contributions to quantum mechanics. A vast amount of study and research has been done by a large number of illustrious physicists in the institute named after him in his home country. His epistemological debates with Einstein are still a subject of a good amount of study.

Happy 128th birthday Niels Bohr!